This past summer, I read an interesting article by Judith Newman at CNN Living about ten questions everyone should ask their mother while they have the chance. It moved me. I’ve always thought a lot about childhoods and family legacies, especially my own. My mom gave my siblings and I what I consider to be pretty awesome childhood, a feat even more remarkable considering my mom was flying blind having lost both her parents at a young age. Now I am parenting my children in a manner different than I would like and differently from how I was raised: my children are in school and daycare full time during the week, whereas I was home playing as a child while my mom baked cookies and acted as our activities director. And so I think a lot about the childhood I’m giving my girls, the childhood I was lucky enough to enjoy, and the childhood my mom experienced.
All of those thoughts were in the background of my mind when I saw the “10 Questions…” article and now I’ve finally had the chance to interview my own mom. She wanted me to stipulate that these are all “thinking questions” as she kept calling them. Hopefully there will be a second take on the interview with more complete answers. I have to admit: I’m terribly curious to see what else my mom has to say and what, if any, answers she changes. Here’s what she had to say:
Q: What’s the one think you would have done differently as a mom?
A: [Immediately:] Spent more time with the kids.
["You spent all your time with us."
"No, nope, no. And you’re going to make me cry with these questions."]
This answer surprised me the most. The way I remember my childhood, my mom was constantly at our disposal. True, she was always doing housework, but she never yelled at us (much) when we interrupted her to help us think of something to do, and she always ate dinner with us, took us on outings, visited family and friends with us. It seemed like my mom was constantly spending time with us. Isn’t it interesting that she would see things so differently?
Q: Why did you choose to be with my father?
A: Because he liked… I liked the way he interacted with old people and with little kids.
[I wasn't surprised by this answer. My mom was raised by her grandmother, who was a little dotty by the time my parents started dating. My mom has told us several stories about how patient my dad was with her grandmother and I can see why she would find that attractive. He is also good - to a point - with children (...who aren't his own). The whole "good with kids" thing is a little ironic since I wouldn't say that any of us are close to him. But I will admit that he can be very good with children when he wants to be.
Q: In what ways do you think I'm like you?
A: Hmmm. You like to read. I don’t know. You’re willing to try to do stuff that you have no clue what you’re doing…like fixing toilets. You sometimes, let me think about these words, umm…we’ll have to go back to that one.
[I was really interested to see how she answered this one. I hope this is one that she expands on when I send her the list of questions to think about, because I am extremely intrigued to get some insight into what she thinks of my character. Family legacies really appeal to me, and I want to see what pieces of her she thinks I've inherited. I want to know what to cling to and what to remember when I lose her.]
Q: Which one of us kids did you like the best?
That’s an unfair question for any mother. Umm…Joe’s my favorite son. You’re my favorite eldest. Rhi’s my fave baby, and poor Kim’s my favorite middle kid.
[I almost chuckled at how seriously she took such an obviously whacked question designed to field the interviewer a compliment. We talked a lot about middle children and second-borns and Bee's status as my second-born. I think my mom did a great job establishing a close bond with each of us kids. I think I was closer to her growing up, if only because I was the second parent and she relied on me so often. She was favorited Kim quite a bit because Kim was a science-nerd like my mom (who came only a few credits short of a masters in biology) and because she was a middle-child like my mom. Joey was her only boy-baby. And Rhi was her baby and her only at-home child now. We all enjoy our title as Mom's Favorite.]
Q: Is there anything you have always wanted to tell me but never have?
A; Hmm…Not that I know of. I don’t know…these are thinking questions. Usually I’m very upfront and I tell anybody…I’ve told you to let the kids break the rules, um…I told you to think hard about The Ex.
Q: There are no lingering secrets from my childhood?
A: No, we told you most of the myths you grew up with (Santa, finding “buried treasure” in the dirt pile [that my dad really planted]). Most of the stuff we told you. Told you how the technical parts of making a baby worked.
A: Yeah, Ma, I already knew that.
[I won't lie - I was hoping to expose a long hidden secret from our family history. Not that we don't have any - they're just all hanging out in the sunshine, I guess.]
Q: Do you think it’s easier or harder to be a mother now than when you were raising our family?
A: I think it’s harder.
Q: Why?
A: Kids are forced to grow up much quicker than before. They have the problem of computers, they have the problem of …I think drugs are so easy to get ahold of.
Q: Is there anything you regret not having asked your parents?
A: That I really don’t know, because I never had any relationship that I know of with either one.
Q: Didn’t your dad [who abandoned her when she was two years old] go to your wedding?
A: No. My father stopped over to Hoot’s house once when [your dad] was there and they walked down to the old-timers [hang out] there and had a beer. Daddy did meet him that once. I probably saw him five times in my life and that’s it. Do I want to ask him why? I… you know it’s one of those thing. I already decided why and I’m sure it’s what he would say.
Q: I wish I could be that decisive. That’s probably the healthiest thing you could have done.
A: What?
Q: Decide “that was that” and move on.
A: Yeah. {pause} He was 32 when my mom died and had 3 kids. 5, 2, and 1. What are you gonna do with that situation?
Q: I’m not judging.
A: Yeah, I know you’re not. Yeah, that’s just what he decided.
Q: Yeah, in that time and age…
A: Yeah, and from what I heard, his mother was a witch from the stories I’d heard. And I know [the stories] are biased. But he had no help. His sister offered to take Carol because she was 5 and would be going to school. Good reason, huh? Actually, I’m glad [things worked out the way they did].
Q: What’s the best thing I can do for you right now?
A: I don’t know.
Q: Don’t cry! I already called dibs. [Editor's note - be warned that these questions will make your mom cry and that will be extremely awkward and cause you to make really bad jokes. Because, ohmygod, is there a worse feeling that hearing your mom cry?]
A: I don’t know. I’m too independent.
Q: Ha! Luckily we can just push you around now. [Almost literally. Her Parkinson's has made her pretty gimpy. Not that's we're horrible children who take advantage of that, or anything. Ahem.]
Q: Is there anything that you wish had been different between us — or that you would still like to change?
A: Yes. I want you to call me when I call you.
Q: I do call you when I can. If I’m busy I can’t just call and have it be a five minute conversation to say I’m busy single-mommying and can’t talk.
A: No judging remember.
Q: I know I’m just explaining.
Q: When did you realize that you were no longer a child?
A: A couple of years ago.
Q: Really?
A: Really. I wasn’t ever going to grow up. How many mothers do you know get new crayons?
Q: You never felt like a grown up before?
A: You didn’t ask that. [Thinking.] I felt like a grown up as soon as we had Jonathan. [Ed. note: They took in my cousin right after their honeymoon.]
Q: It blows my mind that the cousins and I – that we’re the age now that you were when you and all the aunt and uncles were the grownups in charge. And I think, you didn’t feel like this, like you felt like grownups. You must have felt like you knew what you were doing. You must have felt…old and grownup-ish.
A: No!
After that there were more tears and more thinking and my mom decided she’d like to think about more complete answers. I’m glad I interviewed her – even with the jibe about not returning calls. (And before you send hate mail, I swear I talk to her at least every other weekend so we can catch up and she can talk to the girls.) I hope she does give me expanded answers. Maybe I will fill in the answers I thought she would give, or from my own perspective, and then I can barter them with her. That’s another way my mom and I are alike – we both recognize bribery as an excellent motivator!